Now that they are out of the conference, there will never be a real rivalry with Cuse. The party's over.
Look at cincy and xavier, doesnt have to be a conference affiliation that makes for a rivalry. Two things have to happen, we need to play them every year and, more importantly, becoming competitive with them.
Cinci and X, being in the same city, makes that rivalry what it is. While Cuse claims to be NY's team, the geographic distance, combined with their recent dominance over us makes it not a rivalry. Because we are not going to have those frequent head to head matchups, it will never be what it was.
I can tell you that the last time we beat Duke at the Garden, the Duke alum who came to the game with me could not care less about an out of conference loss to a mediocre program. That's what we will be to Cuse going forward. If we are able to become a consistent winner and keep them from raiding the NY/NJ talent pool, then maybe.